Laurie Sutter

As we step into a brand-new year, Laurie and her team want to thank the incredible people of Plymouth and the surrounding areas for 20 wonderful years of support and connection. What began in 2005 has grown into two decades of helping individuals, families, and small businesses protect what matters most.

From our conveniently located office on E. Jefferson Street—and with the ease of today’s technology—we’re here to make insurance simple and approachable. Whether you prefer to stop in, call, or connect by video, our team is ready to help you start the year feeling prepared and confident.

With four licensed representatives and more than 45 years of combined experience, we’re proud to have been recognized multiple times by the Pilot News as Top Insurance Office and Agent. Being chosen by our community year after year is something we never take for granted.

A new year is a natural time to review your coverage and make sure it still fits your life. We offer auto, home, renters, condo, life, and commercial insurance—supporting you through every season and stage, from growing families to growing businesses.

Laurie and her husband, Mark—both Purdue graduates—are proud to call this area home and are raising their family here. Laurie remains actively involved in local organizations like Rotary and Tri Kappa, continuing her commitment to giving back to the community that has shaped her both personally and professionally.

As 2026 begins, let us help you move forward with clarity and a sense of security. Call today for a FREE quote on auto, home, renters, life, or business insurance.

Serving Plymouth and neighboring Indiana communities—Laurie and her team are here for you in the year ahead and beyond.

Proudly serving Indiana zip codes: 46563, 46511, 46501, 46536, 46537, 46513, 46572, 46570, 46504, 46534, 46531, and 46532.