Laurie Sutter

20 Years of Serving Plymouth – Grateful for Every Season With You!

As summer winds down and we begin to welcome the crisp, colorful days of fall, Laurie and her team want to thank the incredible people of Plymouth and the surrounding areas for 20 wonderful years of community and connection.

Since opening our doors back in 2005, it’s been our honor to help make insurance simple and stress-free for individuals, families, and small businesses. From our conveniently located office on E. Jefferson Street—or through a quick phone call or text—we’re here to help you find the coverage that fits your life.

With four licensed representatives and over 50 years of combined experience, we’ve been proud to serve this community and are especially honored to have been named Top Insurance Office and Agent by the Pilot News multiple times. That recognition is meaningful because it comes from you—our neighbors and friends.

Whether you’re getting ready to send kids back to school, preparing your home for cooler weather, or looking ahead to the holidays, now is the perfect time to review your insurance. We offer home, auto, renters, life, condo, and small business policies—protection for every chapter of life.

Laurie and her husband, Mark—both proud Purdue grads—are raising their family right here and remain actively involved in local organizations like Rotary and Tri Kappa. Giving back is our way of saying thank you to the town that has given so much to us.

This season, let us take care of your insurance needs so you can focus on what matters—family, community, and enjoying the changing seasons. Call us today for a FREE quote on auto, home, renters, life, or business insurance.

Serving Plymouth and surrounding Indiana communities with pride and gratitude—Laurie and her team are here for you, in every season.

We’re proud to serve locally in Indiana: 46563, 46511, 46501, 46536, 46537, 46513, 46572, 46570, 46504, 46534, 46531, and 46532.